Jewelry Makeover/Assessment

Is looking in your jewelry box a confusing experience? Do you have jewelry that you wear, but don’t love? Call us. First we will look at what jewelry you have, what you love, what you wear occasionally, and what you don’t wear at all. We will then make suggestions of how to update the pieces you wear infrequently. We can also work with your gems and gold to design new pieces that fit your individual style and complete your jewelry wardrobe. This is not meant to be an appraisal.

Custom Design or Remounting

Our Design staff and Master Goldsmiths excel at helping you create wonderfully unique pieces. We take your ideas, fledgling or full blown, and bring them to life! We will work together to sketch, design, craft, and make your dream a reality. We can often use your own old gold and platinum to create your new jewelry. The precious metal we cannot use, we will give you 50% more than our Guaranteed Highest Scrap Price, in trade.


We offer in-store, full service jewelry repairs on gold, platinum and silver jewelry. We can also have your chipped diamonds recut.

Watch Repairs

Need a new watch battery? In many cases, we can change a battery while you browse in the store. Minor repairs are also taken care of in house while major repairs are handled by our watch experts.

Estate Buying

We buy entire estates or individual pieces of previously enjoyed jewelry, watches, silverware, loose diamonds, dental gold and other unique pieces.

Gold and Precious Metal Buying

Pugh’s Designer Jewelers pays you the guaranteed highest amount for your metal and stones. If someone makes you a higher written offer for your jewelry, we will pay 10% more. We also give 50% more if you trade your jewelry for in store merchandise or labor.


Take your jewelry to our spa! Our fabulous staff will clean and inspect your jewelry free of charge.


We provide insurance appraisals for all diamond and precious gemstone jewelry purchased in our store. In addition, you may have your jewelry items appraised by Michael Myers, G.G. (Graduate Gemologist, G.I.A.) and C.G.A. (Certified Gemologist Appraiser, A.G.S.) Mike offers over 30 years of appraisal experience, DBA Mid-Ohio Gem Lab, located inside our store. Schedule a time to drop off your jewelry items.

Customer Service

In today’s world this may seem old fashioned, but we enjoy giving you a satisfaction guarantee. We are here to walk you through every step of your design or purchase, and you can be fully confident that we will be here after the sale. Excellent service and your complete satisfaction is our desire.